Appeals court hears case of Russian Taliban fighter - KSWO, Lawton, OK- Wichita Falls, TX: News, Weather, Sports. ABC, 24/7, Telemundo -

Appeals court hears case of Russian Taliban fighter

By DENISE LAVOIE
AP Legal Affairs Writer

RICHMOND, Va. (AP) - A former Russian military officer who received a life sentence for leading a Taliban attack on U.S. forces in Afghanistan in 2009 was a soldier, not a criminal, and should have been treated as a lawful combatant, his lawyer argued before a federal appeals court Tuesday.

But a Justice Department lawyer told the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that Irek Hamidullin, who led the attack on behalf of the Taliban and its allied terrorist organization, the Haqqani Network, was not entitled to protections given prisoners of war. He said Taliban members were excluded under a 2002 declaration by then-President George W. Bush.

The three-judge panel peppered both sides with questions about what should determine whether Hamidullin should have been given lawful-combatant status.

Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson III repeatedly questioned Hamidullin's Lawyer, Federal Public Defender Geremy Kamens, about his argument that prosecuting Hamidullin in a civilian court violated the "fundamental concept that soldiers are not criminals."

Wilkinson said that by the time Hamidullin led the attack in 2009, the Taliban was not recognized as a nation state and instead was widely viewed as "a bunch of marauders."

"Taliban fighters are not lawful combatants," Wilkinson said.

Hamidullin, who was captured after being shot and wounded, was the lone survivor among about 30 insurgents. The coalition forces sustained no casualties.

Kamens argued that under the Geneva Conventions and an Army regulation, Hamidullin was entitled to protections as a prisoner of war from the moment he was captured until a military tribunal determined his status. Kamens said Hamidullin has never had a hearing before a tribunal, so he therefore remains a prisoner of war who is immune from ordinary domestic criminal liability.

"It is absolutely clear that this individual is a soldier," Kamens said.

The court first heard arguments last December, but scheduled a second hearing after one of the judges on the panel announced he was stepping down to serve as Baltimore's city solicitor.

Judge Robert King questioned the government's lawyer, Joseph Palmer, about how the government decided that Hamidullin - who spent five years in military detention - would be tried in a civilian court in Virginia. He was sentenced to life in prison in 2015.

King said there appears to be no record of how the decision was made. "That's what troubles me," he said.

Palmer said the government "has never wavered in its determination that Taliban are not eligible for prisoner-of-war status." He said that by 2009, the war in Afghanistan was no longer classified as an international armed conflict, so that prisoner-of-war protections would not apply.

Under the Geneva Convention, the protections apply only during an international armed conflict and if fighters have a leadership hierarchy, a distinctive uniform or insignia, carry arms openly and adhere to the laws of war. The government said Hamidullin was a member of a group that regularly violates the laws of war by targeting civilians.

The U.S. is among nations that distinguish between acts committed by soldiers during war and violent acts outside an international conflict.

There has been only one criminal prosecution in the past 15 years in which a court considered whether a Taliban fighter had combatant immunity. In that case, the judge ruled for the government.

Hamidullin's lawyers are asking the appeals court to throw out his convictions and transfer him to the custody of the U.S. military to determine his status.

The court did not indicate when it would rule.

Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • InternationalMore>>

  • EU nations bicker over migration policy as summit opens

    EU nations bicker over migration policy as summit opens

    Thursday, December 14 2017 4:44 AM EST2017-12-14 09:44:45 GMT
    Friday, December 15 2017 1:26 AM EST2017-12-15 06:26:08 GMT
    EU leaders are gathering in Brussels set to move Brexit talks into a new phase as pressure mounts on Prime Minister May over her plans to take Britain out of the 28-nation bloc.
    EU leaders are gathering in Brussels set to move Brexit talks into a new phase as pressure mounts on Prime Minister May over her plans to take Britain out of the 28-nation bloc.
  • EU's Tusk warns of bruising Brexit battle ahead, urges unity

    EU's Tusk warns of bruising Brexit battle ahead, urges unity

    Thursday, December 14 2017 5:34 AM EST2017-12-14 10:34:47 GMT
    Friday, December 15 2017 1:25 AM EST2017-12-15 06:25:56 GMT
    Britain's chief Brexit negotiator says a situation in which the U.K. crashes out of the European Union without a deal has become "massively less probable" because of a preliminary agreement reached last week.
    Britain's chief Brexit negotiator says a situation in which the U.K. crashes out of the European Union without a deal has become "massively less probable" because of a preliminary agreement reached last week.
  • Peru's president fights back against calls to resign

    Peru's president fights back against calls to resign

    Thursday, December 14 2017 9:55 PM EST2017-12-15 02:55:11 GMT
    Friday, December 15 2017 1:25 AM EST2017-12-15 06:25:52 GMT
    Peruvian President Pedro Pablo Kucyznski is scrambling for his political survival as opponents demand he resign over revelations of decade-old payments from a Brazilian construction company at the center of Latin...
    Peruvian President Pedro Pablo Kucyznski is scrambling for his political survival as opponents demand he resign over revelations of decade-old payments from a Brazilian construction company at the center of Latin America's biggest graft scandal.
  • NationalMore>>

  • FCC votes along party lines to end 'net neutrality'

    FCC votes along party lines to end 'net neutrality'

    Thursday, December 14 2017 1:55 PM EST2017-12-14 18:55:20 GMT
    Friday, December 15 2017 1:27 AM EST2017-12-15 06:27:24 GMT

    FCC votes along party lines to end 'net neutrality' rules that equalized access to the internet.

    FCC votes along party lines to end 'net neutrality' rules that equalized access to the internet.

  • Dueling statistics used at hearing on racial bias in stings

    Dueling statistics used at hearing on racial bias in stings

    Thursday, December 14 2017 1:05 AM EST2017-12-14 06:05:00 GMT
    Friday, December 15 2017 1:27 AM EST2017-12-15 06:27:17 GMT
    (AP Photo/M. Spencer Green File). In this Nov. 25, 2013 file photo, Chief U.S. District Judge Ruben Castillo speaks from the bench in Chicago. A question raised nationwide about whether federal agents display racial bias by staging phony stash-h...(AP Photo/M. Spencer Green File). In this Nov. 25, 2013 file photo, Chief U.S. District Judge Ruben Castillo speaks from the bench in Chicago. A question raised nationwide about whether federal agents display racial bias by staging phony stash-h...

    The question of whether agents display racial bias by staging phony stash-house stings overwhelmingly in black neighborhoods is the focus of landmark hearings in Chicago.

    The question of whether agents display racial bias by staging phony stash-house stings overwhelmingly in black neighborhoods is the focus of landmark hearings in Chicago.

  • Lawmaker who spun history of heroics ends life in suicide

    Lawmaker who spun history of heroics ends life in suicide

    Thursday, December 14 2017 4:04 AM EST2017-12-14 09:04:46 GMT
    Friday, December 15 2017 1:27 AM EST2017-12-15 06:27:10 GMT
    A coroner says a Kentucky lawmaker accused of sexually assaulting a woman has died in an apparent suicide.
    A coroner says a Kentucky lawmaker accused of sexually assaulting a woman has died in an apparent suicide.
Powered by Frankly