Execution by lethal injection cruel and unusual? - KSWO 7News | Breaking News, Weather and Sports

Execution by lethal injection cruel and unusual?

What do you consider a more cruel and unusual punishment; death by lethal injection, electrocution or firing squad?  These are the three execution methods approved in the state of Oklahoma.  But, the U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to hear a case from Kentucky after two death row inmates claim lethal injection is too harsh.

Taylor Stein, former Comanche County District Judge, does not think the justices will put an end to lethal injection as an execution method.  He even doubts that's really what the case is about. 

As a former prosecutor and judge, Stein has seen his fair share of capital murder cases, and the controversy surrounding ultimate punishment.  And, appeals by the two Kentucky death row inmates comes as no surprise to him.  "The real story here is a lot of people oppose the death penalty period," he says.

Even though the U.S. Supreme Court reinstated it as an acceptable punishment for capital murder in 1976, Oklahoma jumped on board and took it a step further by becoming the first state to introduce the lethal injection method. 

"The methodology for execution, I don't think it's cruel, but it has improved over the years and that standard is now set and that standard is not going to go the other direction," says Stein.  And, of course, if lethal injection is considered cruel and unusual, what about the alternatives?  "That would lend credence or credibility to even more arguments that maybe shooting, hanging or electrocution are also cruel and unusual."

Local Defense Attorney Clay Hillis sees the court's decision to hear the case as a housekeeping measure for Federal Circuit Courts.  "They wouldn't want a rule in the 10th circuit that is significantly different in the 9th or 8th circuit and so we have prisoners who get different treatment under federal law depending on where they live," he says.

Hillis doesn't think the court will nix lethal injection, but once they rule on it, it becomes the law of the land.  And, that leaves no room for interpretation by the lower or state courts.  "They could just say everything's fine, let's keep it the way it is, just so they can say they looked at it," Hillis says. 

One of the main arguments against lethal injection is that prisoners are not given enough anesthetic before the drugs that paralyze their muscles and stop their hearts are administered.  The Kentucky inmates claim that it can cause excruciating pain.  But, the court's decision to hear the case did not stop the State of Texas from executing a man by using lethal injection on Tuesday night.

Another prisoner is set to be executed Thursday.

  • Local NewsNewsMore>>

  • US anti-IS office gets reprieve as Syria pullout accelerates

    US anti-IS office gets reprieve as Syria pullout accelerates

    Sunday, May 20 2018 11:21 AM EDT2018-05-20 15:21:26 GMT
    Sunday, May 20 2018 5:43 PM EDT2018-05-20 21:43:40 GMT
    (AP Photo/Hadi Mizban, File). FILE - In this June 7, 2017, file photo, Brett McGurk, the U.S. envoy for the global coalition against IS, speaks during a news conference at the U.S. Embassy Baghdad, Iraq. The Trump administration will keep open the Stat...(AP Photo/Hadi Mizban, File). FILE - In this June 7, 2017, file photo, Brett McGurk, the U.S. envoy for the global coalition against IS, speaks during a news conference at the U.S. Embassy Baghdad, Iraq. The Trump administration will keep open the Stat...

    The State Department unit overseeing the fight against the Islamic State group will stay in business for at least six month more months.

    The State Department unit overseeing the fight against the Islamic State group will stay in business for at least six month more months.

  • Trump to demand DOJ review claims of FBI spy on campaign

    Trump to demand DOJ review claims of FBI spy on campaign

    Sunday, May 20 2018 2:11 PM EDT2018-05-20 18:11:29 GMT
    Sunday, May 20 2018 5:43 PM EDT2018-05-20 21:43:34 GMT
    Trump referred to some who cross the border illegally as "animals," not people. (Source: AP Photo/Evan Vucci)Trump referred to some who cross the border illegally as "animals," not people. (Source: AP Photo/Evan Vucci)

    President Donald Trump says he'll demand that the Justice Department review whether the department or the FBI infiltrated his presidential campaign for political purposes, and whether any demands or requests came...

    President Donald Trump says he'll demand that the Justice Department review whether the department or the FBI infiltrated his presidential campaign for political purposes, and whether any demands or requests came from the Obama administration.

  • Texas mourners endure grief that 'none of us can comprehend'

    Texas mourners endure grief that 'none of us can comprehend'

    Saturday, May 19 2018 11:51 PM EDT2018-05-20 03:51:30 GMT
    Sunday, May 20 2018 5:43 PM EDT2018-05-20 21:43:29 GMT
    (Jennifer Reynolds/The Galveston County Daily News via AP). April Salinas, second from right, her daughters Meah, 13, and Macee, 6, and Jeramiah Kelley read notes left at memorial behind Texas First Bank, Saturday, May 19, 2018 in Santa Fe, Texas. A gu...(Jennifer Reynolds/The Galveston County Daily News via AP). April Salinas, second from right, her daughters Meah, 13, and Macee, 6, and Jeramiah Kelley read notes left at memorial behind Texas First Bank, Saturday, May 19, 2018 in Santa Fe, Texas. A gu...

    The mother of one slain student said her daughter may have been targeted because she rejected advances from the suspect, who was an ex-boyfriend of her daughter's best friend.

    The mother of one slain student said her daughter may have been targeted because she rejected advances from the suspect, who was an ex-boyfriend of her daughter's best friend.

Powered by Frankly